Short term Rental VS Long Term Rental in USA

Short-Term Rentals vs. Long-Term Rentals: Which Is More Profitable?

If you’re diving into real estate investing, the big question often comes down to this: Should you go for short-term rentals (STRs) or long-term rentals (LTRs)? Both have their pros, cons, and profitability factors. But which one aligns with your investment goals? Let’s break it down and analyze this decision like a savvy investor.

1. Understanding Short-Term Rentals

Short-term rentals cater to travelers, vacationers, and business professionals who need a place to stay for a few days to a few weeks. Think Airbnb, Vrbo, and similar platforms.

Key Advantages

  • Higher Income Potential: STRs typically generate higher nightly rates. For example, a property rented at $200 per night for 15 nights earns $3,000 monthly—double the average long-term rental in many markets.
  • Flexibility: You can adjust pricing dynamically based on demand, holidays, and peak seasons.
  • Tax Benefits: If you rent your property for fewer than 14 days per year, the IRS allows you to pocket that income tax-free.

Key Challenges

  • Management Intensive: STRs require regular cleaning, guest communication, and maintenance.
  • Regulations: Many cities are implementing strict regulations on STRs, limiting profitability.
  • Seasonality: Income can fluctuate based on tourism trends and off-seasons.

Stat to Know

According to AirDNA, the average short-term rental earns $43,800 annually, but top-tier properties in tourist-heavy locations can exceed $100,000 per year.

2. Understanding Long-Term Rentals

Long-term rentals involve leasing properties to tenants for extended periods, typically 12 months or more. They cater to individuals and families looking for stable housing.

Key Advantages

  • Stable Cash Flow: Monthly rent provides a consistent income stream, reducing financial volatility.
  • Lower Management Demands: You only need to find tenants once a year, and ongoing maintenance is minimal compared to STRs.
  • Legal Protections: Long-term leases often fall under established landlord-tenant laws, reducing regulatory unpredictability.

Key Challenges

  • Lower Income Potential: Monthly rents are generally lower than the combined income from STRs.
  • Tenant Turnover Costs: When tenants leave, you might face vacancies, cleaning, and repair expenses.
  • Limited Upside: Unlike STRs, you can’t adjust rent frequently to match market trends.

Stat to Know

According to Zillow, the national median rent for a long-term rental in the U.S. was $2,053 in 2024, translating to $24,636 annually per property.

3. Comparing Profitability: A Head-to-Head Analysis

Earnings Potential

  • Short-Term Rentals: Higher earning potential in high-demand locations, such as urban centers, beach destinations, and tourist hotspots.
  • Long-Term Rentals: Reliable but lower income, particularly in areas where housing demand is stable but not booming.

Example: A two-bedroom condo in Miami might generate $60,000 annually as a short-term rental but only $30,000 as a long-term rental.

Expenses

  • Short-Term Rentals:
    • Higher expenses due to cleaning fees, maintenance, utilities, and platform fees (Airbnb takes a 3%-15% cut).
    • Marketing costs to keep the property listed and competitive.
  • Long-Term Rentals:
    • Lower expenses since tenants usually cover utilities.
    • Fewer repair needs because of less frequent turnovers.

Vacancy Rates

  • Short-Term Rentals: Higher vacancy rates during off-seasons or in less popular locations. Average occupancy is 65% in major cities, but it can dip as low as 40% in rural areas.
  • Long-Term Rentals: Lower vacancy rates since tenants typically stay for a year or more, reducing downtime.

Management Requirements

  • Short-Term Rentals:
    • Requires active management or hiring a property manager, which costs 20%-30% of rental income.
  • Long-Term Rentals:
    • Minimal management needed, but you’ll still need to handle lease renewals and occasional repairs.

4. Regulatory Considerations

Short-Term Rentals

STRs face growing scrutiny in cities like New York, Los Angeles, and San Francisco. Local governments are imposing stricter rules, such as limiting the number of rental days per year or requiring special permits.

  • Stat to Know: Over 75% of U.S. cities with active STR markets have implemented or are considering new regulations (Urban Land Institute).

Long-Term Rentals

LTRs are generally less impacted by regulations. Landlord-tenant laws are well-established, giving you a clearer understanding of your rights and responsibilities.

5. Tax Implications

Short-Term Rentals

  • Depreciation and operational expenses are deductible.
  • Income is taxed as ordinary income unless rented for fewer than 14 days annually.

Long-Term Rentals

  • Similar tax benefits, including depreciation and interest deductions.
  • No opportunity for tax-free earnings like STRs under the 14-day rule.

6. Market Conditions and Location

The profitability of both STRs and LTRs depends heavily on location. Here’s how:

  • STR Hotspots: Coastal towns, ski resorts, and major cities with high tourist activity.
  • LTR Hotspots: Suburban areas near job centers, universities, and military bases.

Example: A property in Orlando, Florida, near Disney World might perform significantly better as a short-term rental, while a property in suburban Atlanta could thrive as a long-term rental.

7. Hybrid Strategy: Best of Both Worlds?

Some investors adopt a hybrid approach—using a property as an STR during peak seasons and switching to LTRs during slower months. This strategy maximizes income while reducing risk.

8. Real-Life Case Study

Let’s analyze two properties to compare profitability:

  • Short-Term Rental: A beachfront condo in Santa Monica, California.
    • Annual Revenue: $75,000
    • Expenses: $25,000
    • Net Profit: $50,000
  • Long-Term Rental: A suburban home in Dallas, Texas.
    • Annual Revenue: $28,800 ($2,400/month)
    • Expenses: $6,000
    • Net Profit: $22,800

The STR generates more profit but requires significantly more time and management.

9. Final Verdict: Which Is More Profitable?

There’s no one-size-fits-all answer. It boils down to your investment goals, risk tolerance, and ability to manage properties. Here’s how to decide:

  • Choose STRs if you’re in a high-demand area, can handle active management, and want higher returns.
  • Choose LTRs if you prefer stability, lower management demands, and predictable cash flow.

10. Key Takeaways for Investors

  • Research your market thoroughly. Location is everything.
  • Factor in all expenses, from cleaning fees for STRs to vacancy costs for LTRs.
  • Be mindful of regulations, especially in tourist-heavy cities.
  • Consider starting with LTRs if you’re new to real estate and transitioning to STRs as you gain experience.

Final Thoughts

Real estate investing is about playing the long game. Whether you choose short-term rentals, long-term rentals, or a mix of both, the key is understanding your market, running the numbers, and staying adaptable. Start small, learn from every deal, and watch your portfolio grow. As always, make your money work as hard as you do. Happy investing!

Popup

Name(Required)
Are You(Required)